House of missionaries David Belden Lyman and Sarah Joiner Lyman, built in 1838, now a museum in Hilo, Hawaii
House of missionaries David Belden Lyman and Sarah Joiner Lyman, built in 1838, now a museum in Hilo, Hawaii

Lyman House Memorial Museum

museumshistoryarchitecturehawaiimissionaries
4 min read

There is a mineral called orlymanite. It is named for Orlando Hammond Lyman, great-grandson of the missionaries who built this house in 1839, and it sits in the museum collection like a geological footnote to a family story that spans nearly two centuries. The Lyman House in Hilo is the oldest surviving wood-framed building on the Big Island of Hawaii - a New England saltbox constructed from native koa and ohia wood, standing on a street where thatched meeting houses once served a Hawaiian congregation. It is a place where two worlds met, and where the evidence of that meeting has been carefully preserved.

Six Months to Paradise

Reverend David Belden Lyman and his wife Sarah Joiner Lyman had been married for all of twenty-four days when they boarded a ship bound for Hawaii in 1832, sent by the American Board of Commissioners for Foreign Missions. The six-month voyage delivered them to a landscape utterly unlike their native New England, yet the house they built reflected the world they had left behind. Its frame echoed the proportions of a Connecticut farmhouse, but the timbers were koa - the same dense, curving hardwood that Hawaiians used for war canoes - and ohia, harvested from the rainforests above Hilo. The result was something genuinely hybrid: a building that looked like New England but was made entirely of Hawaii.

The Guest Book

Over the decades, the Lyman House became a stopping point for travelers whose names would later fill history books. Mark Twain stayed here during his 1866 visit to the islands, the trip that produced some of his earliest travel writing. Isabella Bird, the Victorian explorer who would go on to traverse the Rocky Mountains alone on horseback, also slept under this roof during her 1873 Hawaiian journey. The house saw Hawaiian ali'i - royalty - pass through as well, and across the street, Haili Church rose between 1854 and 1859 to replace the thatched structures where the congregation had previously gathered. The Lymans founded the Hilo Boarding School nearby, educating young Hawaiian men. The missionary footprint in Hilo was deep, and this house was its domestic center - the place where the public mission became private life.

From Home to Heritage

Almost a century after David and Sarah arrived, their descendants founded a museum in the house in 1931. The family understood that the building itself had become an artifact - not just of missionary life but of a vanished era in Hawaiian history. The mission house was added to the National Register of Historic Places on March 24, 1978. By that time, the collections had outgrown the original structure. In the late 1960s, the renowned Hawaii-based architect Vladimir Ossipoff designed a modern museum building adjacent to the mission house. Ossipoff, known for his mid-century tropical modernism, created a space where the old and new could coexist without competing. The main collections moved next door, while the house itself remained open for tours - a living exhibit of missionary-era domesticity.

Shells, Stones, and Smithsonian Standing

The museum that grew from the Lyman family's collections is now renowned for its holdings in shells and minerals - a reflection of Hawaii's extraordinary natural diversity and the collectors who spent lifetimes cataloging it. The mineral orlymanite, a zinc-manganese silicate hydroxide, was named in honor of Orlando Hammond Lyman, the museum's founder, who dedicated much of his life to assembling the mineral collection. The museum has been a Smithsonian Institution affiliate since 2002, a recognition that places it alongside the nation's most significant cultural repositories. Its exhibits on Hawaiian culture draw connections between the natural world and the human communities shaped by it - the geology that created the islands, the ocean currents that brought the Polynesians, the volcanic soil that sustained them. At 276 Haili Street, a wooden house built by two newlyweds from New England still stands, holding the story of how strangers became residents and how a family home became a public trust.

From the Air

Located at 19.722°N, 155.091°W in downtown Hilo, on the windward coast of Hawaii Island. The museum sits on Haili Street near Haili Church, a few blocks inland from Hilo Bay. Best viewed at 2,000-3,000 feet AGL. Nearest airport: PHTO (Hilo International Airport), approximately 2 miles southeast. From the air, look for the contrast between the older wooden mission house and the adjacent modern museum building designed by Vladimir Ossipoff.