Qualla: Murder of Mona Tinsley

Murder of Mona Tinsley: Introduction

Wed, 27 May 2026 00:00:00 GMT

Mona Lilian Tinsley was ten years old. She lived in Newark-on-Trent with her parents Wilfred and Lilian and her six brothers and sisters. She attended the Guildhall Street Methodist School in Newark, and on Tuesday 5 January 1937, she left school in the early afternoon and never came home. She is what this story is about. The eight months that followed gave her parents almost nothing in the way of answers; they would walk to the police station, walk home again, wait, and start over the next morning. The rest of what happened to Mona belongs to a courtroom and a Sheffield man named Frederick Nodder, but the heart of the case is a child who should have walked home through a Newark winter afternoon, and didn't.

Read more: Murder of Mona Tinsley on Qualla

Murder of Mona Tinsley: A Family of Nine

Wed, 27 May 2026 00:00:00 GMT

The Tinsleys were ordinary people in an ordinary house, and Mona was, by every contemporary description, a bright and friendly child. The previous autumn the family had taken in a lodger introduced to them by Lilian's sister, Edith Grimes of Sheffield, where the same man had prev...

Read more: Murder of Mona Tinsley on Qualla

Murder of Mona Tinsley: The Afternoon Mona Disappeared

Wed, 27 May 2026 00:00:00 GMT

What is known of Tuesday 5 January is pieced together from witnesses who came forward in the days that followed. A neighbour of the Tinsleys saw Nodder loitering on a street corner near the school, staring toward the entrance, on the afternoon Mona was due to leave. A bus conduct...

Read more: Murder of Mona Tinsley on Qualla

Murder of Mona Tinsley: The Long Search

Wed, 27 May 2026 00:00:00 GMT

Mona's parents waited. So did her brothers and sisters. So did most of Newark. The local force searched Peacehaven, drained five miles of the Chesterfield Canal, and combed every drain, ditch, pond, and cesspit within three miles of Nodder's house. After three weeks of finding no...

Read more: Murder of Mona Tinsley on Qualla

Murder of Mona Tinsley: The River Idle

Wed, 27 May 2026 00:00:00 GMT

On 6 June 1937, a family boating on the River Idle near Bawtry noticed something caught in a drain below the waterline. It was Mona. Her body had been weighted with wood and metal; a rotting sack lay on the bank above her. The location was about eight miles from Peacehaven. The p...

Read more: Murder of Mona Tinsley on Qualla