Eight games, eight losses, and then oblivion. The Elizabeth Resolutes played every one of their 1873 home games at the Waverly Fairgrounds, a stretch of land straddling what is now the border between Newark and Elizabeth, New Jersey. They lost all eight. Their full-season record of 2-21 stands as one of the most dismal in the history of professional baseball. But Waverly's story is not really about baseball's failures -- it is about a piece of ground that served one purpose after another for half a century, each chapter erasing the last, until the land itself was transformed into something unrecognizable.
The New Jersey State Fair called Waverly home from 1867 through 1898, more than three decades of agricultural exhibitions, livestock competitions, and the spectacle that drew the biggest crowds: horse racing. A half-mile racing oval anchored the grounds, and equestrian events continued there well into the 20th century. The community of Waverly sat bordered by Lower Road (now Dayton Avenue), Haynes Avenue, and Frelinghuysen Street -- a patch of land that belonged to neither Newark nor Elizabeth in any cultural sense, but straddled both. President Ulysses S. Grant attended the races in 1872, lending the oval a brushstroke of national prestige.
The Elizabeth Resolutes began around 1869 as an independent club, staging games at Waverly against New York-area teams, including members of the National Association of Professional Base Ball Players. In 1873, the Resolutes joined the NA -- what some historians count as the first major league -- and played their home schedule at Waverly from April 28 through July 23. Where exactly the diamond sat is uncertain; based on common practice at other fairground ballparks, it likely occupied the infield of the racing oval. The Resolutes' eight home games produced nothing but defeat, part of a 2-21 season that ended the club altogether. The exact location of the baseball diamond may be lost, but the scale of the failure is precisely documented.
When the state fair era ended in 1898, Essex County purchased the land for redevelopment. The transformation that followed was sweeping. What had been open fairground became Weequahic Park, designed by the Olmsted Brothers firm and shaped into one of Newark's defining green spaces, with an 80-acre lake, walking trails, and athletic fields. Part of the old Waverly property also became B'nai Jeshuron Cemetery in Elizabeth. The racing oval survived the transition in a ghostly way -- its footprint persists as an oval-shaped roadway within the park, now called the Rev. Ronald B. Christian Recreation Complex. Inside the oval, a modern football field, a 400-meter track, and softball diamonds sit where horses once thundered and the Resolutes once lost.
Nothing at Waverly's former site announces what once stood there. No plaque marks the spot where the Resolutes took the field, no grandstand foundation peeks through the grass. The state fair's three decades have left no visible trace. But the land's shape remembers. That oval roadway in Weequahic Park, gently curving through the South Ward, follows the exact path of the racing track that predated the park by at least half a century. It is a reminder that landscapes carry their history in geometry even when every structure has been razed and every purpose forgotten. For those who count the National Association as a major league, this quiet stretch of Newark parkland qualifies as hallowed ground -- the worst team in baseball once called it home.
The former Waverly Fairgrounds site is located at approximately 40.693N, 74.205W, now occupied by Weequahic Park in Newark's South Ward. From the air, the oval-shaped roadway of the Rev. Ronald B. Christian Recreation Complex is clearly visible and marks the footprint of the old racing oval. Newark Liberty International Airport (KEWR) lies just east of the park. Recommended viewing altitude: 2,000-3,000 feet AGL.