Three Hollywood stars walked away from the cameras in 1947 and did something unexpected: they started a theater. Gregory Peck, Dorothy McGuire, and Mel Ferrer were already famous, already wealthy, already the kind of people who didn't need to prove anything. And yet they kept coming back to La Jolla every summer, convinced that the best work of their careers might happen not on a sound stage but in front of a live audience.
The La Jolla Playhouse opened its first season in 1947 in a converted movie house near the University of California campus. The three founders brought in fellow actors, directors, and designers who were willing to work for scale — sometimes less — because the work itself was the draw. Their gamble was simple: talented people, given freedom from studio interference, might make something genuinely surprising.
For twelve summers, they did exactly that. The playhouse attracted some of the most significant theater and film artists of the era, staging adventurous productions that audiences in San Diego wouldn't see anywhere else. Then, in 1958, the original run ended. The founding trio had aging careers, the economics were punishing, and the summer theater model had run its course. For nearly two and a half decades, La Jolla had no playhouse.
The revival came from an unexpected direction. In 1983, the University of California San Diego partnered with a new nonprofit organization to reopen the playhouse on the university campus. Under artistic director Des McAnuff, it found a new identity — not as a celebrity showcase or a summer retreat, but as a serious producing theater committed to developing new American plays and musicals.
Within a decade, the strategy was vindicated. In 1993, the La Jolla Playhouse received the Tony Award for Outstanding Regional Theatre, one of the most prestigious recognitions in American theater. It confirmed what local audiences already knew: that something significant was happening on that campus by the Pacific, far from Broadway's usual geography.
The Playhouse's most lasting contribution to American theater has been its role as a development laboratory. Productions incubated in La Jolla have traveled to Broadway more than three dozen times, carrying the theater's imprint into the mainstream of American culture.
The list is remarkable for its range. Jersey Boys — the story of the Four Seasons — found its shape here before its long Broadway run. Come from Away, the musical about the Newfoundland town that sheltered passengers stranded by the September 11 attacks, was developed and premiered at the Playhouse before becoming an international phenomenon. Tommy, The Who's rock opera translated into full theatrical form, took flight here. Each of these productions arrived in New York already tested, already shaped by the particular creative freedom La Jolla affords.
That freedom comes partly from geography. Distance from New York creates a different kind of pressure — or rather, removes certain pressures. Collaborators can take risks in La Jolla that feel prohibitive closer to the critics and investors who define Broadway success. The works that survive that process arrive toughened and clarified.
Today the Playhouse occupies three performance spaces on the UCSD campus in the Torrey Pines neighborhood, each designed for a different kind of theatrical experience. The Mandell Weiss Theatre seats more than 500 for large productions. The smaller Mandell Weiss Forum allows for more intimate work. The outdoor Potiker Theatre opens theater to San Diego's particular gift: the kind of evening air that makes an audience feel both exposed to the world and enclosed within the story.
The campus setting keeps the Playhouse in conversation with the university's academic and artistic programs, creating a constant flow of new voices alongside established ones. Student audiences, faculty collaborators, and community members share the same houses, sometimes watching the same productions with different layers of comprehension. That mix has always been part of what Gregory Peck and his fellow founders were reaching for — the sense that theater is a civic act, not just an entertainment, and that it belongs to everyone who shows up.
La Jolla Playhouse sits on the UCSD campus near Torrey Pines, visible from the air as part of the university's mesa-top complex overlooking the Pacific coast.