Cross Keys

civil war battlefieldsshape note singingshenandoah valleyrockingham county
4 min read

Once a year, shape-note singers gather at a small cemetery in Cross Keys, Virginia, and sing a hymn called Retirement at a particular headstone. The grave belongs to Ananias Davisson, who published the first Southern shape-note tunebook - the Kentucky Harmony, in 1816 - and whose compositions still circulate through American congregational singing today. The crossroads has fewer than a hundred residents. It has no incorporated government. But two things have happened here that have stayed in the historical record: a Civil War battle won by Stonewall Jackson in 1862, and the long musical tradition that traces its first published book to one of Cross Keys's own.

A Crossroads in the Valley

Cross Keys sits along State Route 276 south of Harrisonburg in Rockingham County. The name comes from the keys-and-bow tavern sign that hung at the crossroads in the early 19th century - a not-uncommon naming convention for rural Virginia communities. The land surrounding the crossroads has been farmed for generations: limestone soil, gently rolling, productive. From the air, the community is barely a community at all - a few houses, the cemetery, the road junction. The Shenandoah Valley spreads in every direction. Massanutten Mountain rises to the north and east; the Allegheny Front lies to the west; the Blue Ridge edges the eastern horizon.

The Battle of Cross Keys

On June 8, 1862, two days after the small skirmish at Good's Farm that killed Turner Ashby, Cross Keys became the site of a much larger Civil War engagement. The Battle of Cross Keys was a Confederate victory in Stonewall Jackson's celebrated Valley Campaign. Union General John C. Fremont's force - about 11,500 men - met Confederate division under General Richard Ewell, about 5,800 men, in fields and woodlots around the crossroads. The Union attack was poorly coordinated; the Confederate defense, anchored by veterans of earlier Valley battles, held and counterattacked. Casualties on both sides numbered in the hundreds. Jackson's Valley Campaign that spring continues to be studied at military academies as a model of how a smaller force can defeat larger forces through speed and concentration. Cross Keys is one of the campaign's victories. The battlefield is partially preserved by the American Battlefield Trust.

Ananias Davisson and Shape-Note Singing

Ananias Davisson (1780-1857) was a printer and singing-school teacher from the Shenandoah Valley who collected hymn tunes and folk songs and published them in shaped notation - a system in which each note of the scale has a distinctive head shape, making sight-singing more accessible. His Kentucky Harmony, published in 1816, was the first shape-note tunebook produced in the South. The title was geographic in origin - many of the songs he had collected came from Kentucky and Tennessee, where he had traveled to teach singing schools - but the tradition he helped seed took root from the Shenandoah Valley south through Appalachia and the Deep South. Sacred Harp singing, Christian Harmony, the entire surviving tradition of shape-note congregational singing - they all trace lineage back through Davisson's work.

Retirement at the Graveside

Davisson is buried in the Cross Keys cemetery. Each year, the Northern Shenandoah Valley All Day Shenandoah Harmony Singing - a daylong event that uses the modern Shenandoah Harmony tunebook, which republishes many of Davisson's compositions - ends with a procession to the cemetery. The singers gather around the headstone and sing Davisson's hymn Retirement at his grave. The hymn is in a minor key, sung in four parts, and shape-note singers do not perform - they sing for themselves and the room (or in this case, the cemetery air). Audio recordings of the graveside singing exist, and they preserve something unusual: a living musical tradition acknowledging its first publisher, two centuries on, in the small place he came from. The crossroads is quiet most of the year. Once a year, in a particular hour, it is full of harmony.

From the Air

Located at 38.3592N, 78.8419W in Rockingham County, Virginia, south of Harrisonburg in the Shenandoah Valley. Cross Keys is a small unincorporated community along State Route 276. Recommended viewing altitude is 3,500 to 5,500 feet for views of the gently rolling agricultural Valley. Massanutten Mountain rises north and east; the Blue Ridge runs along the eastern horizon. Nearest airport is Shenandoah Valley Regional (KSHD) about 8 nm south. Watch for valley haze in summer.