Sign based on photograph with front view of a Turkmenistan Airlines Boeing 757 landing at London Heathrow Airport, England. The registration is not known. Photographed by Adrian Pingstone in June 2004 and released to the public domain.
Sign based on photograph with front view of a Turkmenistan Airlines Boeing 757 landing at London Heathrow Airport, England. The registration is not known. Photographed by Adrian Pingstone in June 2004 and released to the public domain.

2016 Indonesian Air Force C-130 Crash

Aviation accidents and incidents in 2016Aviation accidents and incidents in IndonesiaAccidents and incidents involving the Lockheed C-130 HerculesIndonesian Air ForceControlled flight into terrain
4 min read

It was 6:02 on a foggy Papuan morning when the Indonesian Air Force C-130 called Wamena Tower for landing. The Hercules had lifted off from Timika at 5:35, carrying twelve crew members, one passenger, and twelve tonnes of logistics into the highland hub of Wamena. Visibility was poor. The tower suggested switching the approach from Runway 15 to Runway 33, and the pilot, Major Marlon A Kawer, agreed. At 6:08 the controllers caught the aircraft visually in the murk. Sixty seconds later, they lost it. The Hercules had struck Mount Lisuwa on short final, near the Runway 33 threshold, in cloud so thick the mountain itself was invisible to the crew a minute before impact.

A New Aircraft on Its First Highland Winter

The C-130H Hercules that went down near Wamena had been in Indonesian service for only nine months. It had been delivered in March 2016 from Australia - the first of five ex-Royal Australian Air Force Hercules that Indonesia had purchased as part of a planned fleet expansion that would eventually bring up to sixteen more aircraft into service. The airframe had logged about 9,000 flight hours and was newly inducted into the TNI-AU fleet. Indonesian Air Force Vice Chief Hadiyan Sumintaatmadja would later emphasize that the aircraft was airworthy and had received routine 50-hour maintenance checks. Whatever caused the crash, he said, was not a mechanical failure.

The Runway Change That Did Not Save Them

Wamena sits at about 5,400 feet in the Baliem Valley, surrounded by high country. Its main runway, 15/33, runs roughly between Mount Lisuwa to the north and other peaks to the south. Morning weather in the Baliem is notoriously volatile - the valley can fill with cold fog that drifts down from the surrounding ridges and sits until the sun has climbed well above the horizon. When Wamena Tower suggested that the inbound Hercules switch from Runway 15 to Runway 33 because of poor visibility on the original approach, they were giving the crew what should have been a safer option. The change meant approaching the airfield from a different direction, over different terrain. But fog was not limited to one side. Mount Lisuwa stood near the new approach course, and the crew, hand-flying in the cloud, struck it.

Thirteen Dead

All thirteen people aboard died on impact. The wreckage came to rest burned, the tail section detached from the main fuselage. A crisis center was established at Sentani Airport, and thirty Air Force personnel were deployed to the site; because the wreckage lay near the approach end of the runway, recovery was not as logistically brutal as some of Papua's more remote crashes, but the work of identifying the dead in burned and fragmented condition fell to three Disaster Victim Identification teams. By noon on 18 December, ten of the thirteen victims had been identified. The bodies were carried down from the site, transported to the nearest airport, and flown to Malang in East Java for a military repatriation ceremony. Major Kawer, the pilot in command, was among them.

An Aging Fleet, an Outcry

Indonesian public reaction was immediate. The C-130 fleet of the TNI-AU had suffered a series of crashes in the preceding years, most notably the 2015 Hercules crash in Medan that killed 139 people. Many Indonesians demanded a complete grounding of the Hercules fleet; some questioned why an air force this large was still operating transport aircraft that dated, in some cases, from the 1960s. The commander of the Indonesian Armed Forces, Gatot Nurmantyo, rejected the grounding calls on practical grounds - only the Hercules, he said, had the range and payload to reach every island in the archipelago. President Joko Widodo ordered a comprehensive review of maintenance practices across the armed forces. Defense Minister Ryamizard Ryacudu was called before the People's Representative Council to answer for the accident. The Air Force announced it would re-engine its entire Hercules fleet.

A Mountain That Keeps Its Name

Mount Lisuwa, the peak that stopped Flight 9760D at Wamena, is one of the ridges that ring the Baliem Valley - the same valley that Australian patrol officer Mick Leahy first flew over in 1938, looking down in astonishment at a civilization of 50,000 Dani farmers no European had ever seen. In the decades since, Wamena has become the primary airhead for highland Papua. Its weather has also become infamous. Pilots who fly the Baliem call the early morning approach the most demanding routine operation in Indonesian civil aviation. Mount Lisuwa is not marked on any passenger brochure. It does not rank on any list of Indonesia's greatest peaks. But for the families of the thirteen crew and passengers aboard a Hercules on 18 December 2016, it is a name that will not be forgotten.

From the Air

Crash site near 4.11S, 138.97E, on Mount Lisuwa adjacent to Wamena Airport (WAVV/WMX) in the Baliem Valley. Wamena sits at approximately 5,400ft MSL in a highland valley surrounded by peaks exceeding 4,000m. The airport is the primary airhead for highland Papua and handles mixed commercial, mission, and military traffic. Morning fog fills the valley regularly and is the single greatest operational hazard; approach procedures are VFR-dominant and time-of-day critical. Timika (WABP/TIM) on the south coast and Sentani (WAJJ/DJJ) near Jayapura serve as the primary feeders into Wamena. Cruise at FL250+ for a highland overview; approach requires current weather and a briefed alternate.